Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom

Validation error in TestAllocationAliasing on AMD Ryzen™ 9 7950X #338

Open
IAmNotHanni opened this issue May 14, 2023 · 1 comment
Open

Validation error in TestAllocationAliasing on AMD Ryzen™ 9 7950X #338

IAmNotHanni opened this issue May 14, 2023 · 1 comment
Labels
bug Something isn't working investigating Still to be determined whether we work on this

Comments

@IAmNotHanni
Copy link
Contributor

IAmNotHanni commented May 14, 2023 •
edited
Loading

Hello

When running VulkanSample application's tests with my AMD 7950X (AMD Radeon(TM) Graphics), I get a validation error caused by TestAllocationAliasing(). Running the tests with my Intel Arc A770 works without any problems. (I use the --GPUIndex command line to enforce which physical device will be chosen)

When I continue the tests, there is another issue with ProcessDefragmentationPass, but I will create a separate issue for this.

Vulkan Memory Allocator Sample 3.0.1
Vulkan API version used: 1.3
physicalDeviceProperties:
    driverVersion: 0x8000FA
    vendorID: 0x1002 (AMD)
    deviceID: 0x164E
    deviceType: 1 (INTEGRATED_GPU)
    deviceName: AMD Radeon(TM) Graphics
    limits:
        maxMemoryAllocationCount: 4096
        bufferImageGranularity: 1 B
        nonCoherentAtomSize: 128 B
physicalDeviceVulkan11Properties:
    maxMemoryAllocationSize: 2147483648 B (2.00 GB)
physicalDeviceVulkan12Properties:
    driverID: 1 (AMD_PROPRIETARY)
    driverName: AMD proprietary driver
    driverInfo: 22.40.40 (AMD proprietary shader compiler)

MEMORY HEAPS:
heapCount=3, typeCount=8
Heap 0: 268435456 B (256.00 MB) DEVICE_LOCAL, MULTI_INSTANCE
    Type 0: DEVICE_LOCAL
    Type 4: DEVICE_LOCAL, DEVICE_COHERENT (AMD), DEVICE_UNCACHED (AMD)
Heap 1: 16437477376 B (15.31 GB)
    Type 1: HOST_VISIBLE, HOST_COHERENT
    Type 3: HOST_VISIBLE, HOST_COHERENT, HOST_CACHED
    Type 5: HOST_VISIBLE, HOST_COHERENT, DEVICE_COHERENT (AMD), DEVICE_UNCACHED (AMD)
    Type 7: HOST_VISIBLE, HOST_COHERENT, HOST_CACHED, DEVICE_COHERENT (AMD), DEVICE_UNCACHED (AMD)
Heap 2: 268435456 B (256.00 MB) DEVICE_LOCAL, MULTI_INSTANCE
    Type 2: DEVICE_LOCAL, HOST_VISIBLE, HOST_COHERENT
    Type 6: DEVICE_LOCAL, HOST_VISIBLE, HOST_COHERENT, DEVICE_COHERENT (AMD), DEVICE_UNCACHED (AMD)

Conclusions:
- 2 heaps are DEVICE_LOCAL, total 512.00 MB.
- 2 heaps are HOST_VISIBLE, total 15.56 GB.
- 1 heaps are DEVICE_LOCAL and HOST_VISIBLE, total 256.00 MB.
- No types are HOST_VISIBLE but not HOST_COHERENT.
- No types are not DEVICE_LOCAL and not HOST_VISIBLE.
- 4 types are AMD-specific DEVICE_COHERENT or DEVICE_UNCACHED.
- No types are LAZILY_ALLOCATED.
- A buffer with VERTEX_BUFFER usage can be created in some non-DEVICE_LOCAL type.
- An image with OPTIMAL tiling and SAMPLED usage can be created in some non-DEVICE_LOCAL type.

Enabled extensions and features:
Validation layer: 1
Sparse binding: 1
VK_EXT_memory_budget: 1
VK_AMD_device_coherent_memory: 1
bufferDeviceAddress: 1
VK_EXT_memory_priority: 1

TESTING:
Test JSON
Saving JSON dump to file "JSON_VULKAN.json"
Test basics
Test vnaGetAllocatorInfo
Test virtual blocks
Test virtual blocks algorithms
Benchmark virtual blocks algorithms
Alignment,Algorithm,Strategy,Alloc time ms,Random operation time ms,Free time ms
1,TLSF,Default,0.5684,1.802,0.6351
1,Linear,Default,0.6116,2.0894,1.0173
1,TLSF,MIN_MEMORY,0.4404,1.7821,0.6319
1,Linear,MIN_MEMORY,0.3802,1.8538,0.9999
1,TLSF,MIN_TIME,0.421,1.7144,0.6522
1,Linear,MIN_TIME,0.3785,1.9067,0.9979
16,TLSF,Default,1.4293,2.2369,0.6939
16,Linear,Default,0.3765,1.8518,1.0022
16,TLSF,MIN_MEMORY,1.8616,3.6379,0.7029
16,Linear,MIN_MEMORY,0.3808,1.8713,1.0271
16,TLSF,MIN_TIME,0.7092,2.1489,0.7045
16,Linear,MIN_TIME,0.3808,1.8795,1.0175
64,TLSF,Default,1.6448,4.1676,0.7037
64,Linear,Default,0.3809,1.8937,1.0152
64,TLSF,MIN_MEMORY,1.817,4.6938,0.6869
64,Linear,MIN_MEMORY,0.3966,2.0087,1.0144
64,TLSF,MIN_TIME,0.7245,2.0992,0.7062
64,Linear,MIN_TIME,0.3808,1.8716,1.0115
256,TLSF,Default,1.8157,4.7682,0.7052
256,Linear,Default,0.3891,1.8862,1.0088
256,TLSF,MIN_MEMORY,1.8568,4.765,0.6778
256,Linear,MIN_MEMORY,0.3837,1.8848,1.0349
256,TLSF,MIN_TIME,0.7472,2.0387,0.7257
256,Linear,MIN_TIME,0.382,1.8839,1.0164
Test allocation versus resource size
Test Pool MinBlockCount
Test Pool MinAllocationAlignment
Test pools and allocation parameters
Test heap size limit
Testing memory usage:
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_UNKNOWN:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_GPU_ONLY:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=0
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_CPU_ONLY:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_CPU_TO_GPU:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=2
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=2
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=2
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=2
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=2
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_GPU_TO_CPU:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=3
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=3
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=3
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=3
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=3
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_CPU_COPY:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, memoryTypeIndex=1
  VMA_MEMORY_USAGE_GPU_LAZILY_ALLOCATED:
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, FAILED with res=-8
    Buffer TRANSFER_DST + VERTEX_BUFFER: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, FAILED with res=-8
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + TRANSFER_SRC: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, FAILED with res=-8
    Image OPTIMAL TRANSFER_DST + SAMPLED: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, FAILED with res=-8
    Image OPTIMAL SAMPLED + COLOR_ATTACHMENT: memoryTypeBits=0xFF, FAILED with res=-8
Testing device coherent memory...
Testing budget...
Testing aliasing...
  size: max(1441792, 8896880) = 8896880
  alignment: max(65536, 65536) = 65536
  memoryTypeBits: 255 & 255 = 255
Testing allocation aliasing...
VUID-vkAllocateMemory-pAllocateInfo-01713 ║ Validation Error: [ VUID-vkAllocateMemory-pAllocateInfo-01713 ] Object 0: handle = 
0x1cbd17a8e20, type = VK_OBJECT_TYPE_DEVICE; | MessageID = 0xe9a2b96f | vkAllocateMemory: attempting to allocate 314572800 
bytes from heap 0,but size of that heap is only 268435456 bytes. The Vulkan spec states: pAllocateInfo->allocationSize must be less than 
or equal to VkPhysicalDeviceMemoryProperties::memoryHeaps[memindex].size where memindex = 
VkPhysicalDeviceMemoryProperties::memoryTypes[pAllocateInfo->memoryTypeIndex].heapIndex as returned by 
vkGetPhysicalDeviceMemoryProperties for the VkPhysicalDevice that device was created from (https://vulkan.lunarg.com/doc/view
/1.3.246.0/windows/1.3-extensions/vkspec.html#VUID-vkAllocateMemory-pAllocateInfo-01713)
@IAmNotHanni
Copy link
Contributor Author

I will look into this and try to find a solution for the problem.

@IAmNotHanni IAmNotHanni mentioned this issue May 14, 2023
Open
@adam-sawicki-a adam-sawicki-a added bug Something isn't working investigating Still to be determined whether we work on this labels May 18, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
bug Something isn't working investigating Still to be determined whether we work on this
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

No branches or pull requests
2 participants
@IAmNotHanni @adam-sawicki-a